I LEFT SCHOOL WHEN I WAS 12 BEFORE THEY COULD EDUCATE THE INTELLIGENCE OUT OF ME .
About 6years ago I was going to return to school as a mature student and study to be an auctioneer and valuer (it looked like a good move back then) As a mature student my application would be by interview so I started to read up on the property market in preparation for my interview .It became obvious to me a secondary school dropout that something was wrong very wrong So I prepared my self for my interview armed with all the facts and figures i could muster and a speel about wanting to be able to help people find the house of their dreams .Forgetting that this was an interview to go to collage not get a job.
When I got to the interview they had no interest in what I knew only if I would stick to the course for the full two years.The guy doing the interview told me I had made a good choice of career move as the property market was on the up and he could see it carrying on for some time .He explained that trading up was the biggest earner in the industry .You get to sell the existing premises and possibly find the new one .
I then asked could he not see a problem in the property market .Did he not see the flaw.What flaw he asked .So I offered this example Dublin Corporation sold off their housing stock at great discount to the market .This had reduced the available social housing .So it had become the norm for working people to buy their own homes.I bought my house for 10400 punt or about 14000Euro in1988.In the height of the boom the house next door to me sold for 240,000 euro .Now where I live is a very working class area people have to work to survive .So I offered this example .I defined working class as an average wage earner.
He drives a forklift in a factory .She works in the office in the same place .
INCOME
Him =takehome 460
Her =……………..460
Allow 10% for personal use a pint a paper or a smoke -92 or 41 euro each
Car to get to work =petrol maintenance insurance purchase price =128 per week
Feed and cloth two adults and two children .Electricity ,Heat ,Tv ,Phone =500 per week
You have 200 a week left to pay for a Mortgage and insurance policy .I calculated that the largest mortgage that you could afford over 25 years and be comfortable that you could make the payments on was 85,000.So my argument was that if all you could afford to pay was 85,000 then the true value of the property was 85,000 and not 240,000 So the thing was that based on your ability to pay the property market was on average 60% overvalued . The man with the degree doing the interview told me I was wrong
I believed I was right so when I was offered a place on the course I declined .I backed my own judgement .Now the thing is I left school at twelve and I could see the problem.I would never be able to get a job with a bank im not smart enough for them.For those worried about our average couple .They save the monthly childrens allowance to pay for school books ,Christmas and a weeks holiday in Kilmuckridge
Since I first wrote this things have changed .The new Social Charge ,Property Tax and Water charges will impact greatly on your spending power .I now suggest that a 3 bedroom xcouncil house in Dublin is worth about 60.000€ and you can add a little extra for the availability of local schools ,shops and bus or Luas service . Privately built houses in close proximity to council houses are worth very little more .In some cases the x council house is better proportioned ,better built and has larger gardens .
Two bedroomed apartments are worth considerably less than houses and one bedroomed apartments are probably unsalable.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Now here is the thing.Homes .ie still quote houses in my estate at 170.000 euro .So they are still overpriced .If the government allow the market to truly find its own true worth the losses incurred by NAMA on their property portfolio will destroy the economic recovery So the catch 22 is do the government allow the market to correct itself or do they introduce new tax cuts or reliefs to protect their investment .If they introduce tax breaks to stimulate sales then they protect their investment but the downside is we the purchaser pay over the odds for our homes.The plus side of inflating house prices is that those of us who own homes will benefit from the inflated price and those who have existing mortgages will be insentivised to continue payments and not default.So heads you lose, tails you lose
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
THE National Treasury Management Agency (NTMA) says house prices here have further to fall as disposable incomes also decline.
The views are revealed in a wide-ranging review of the economy published by the NTMA last night which was shown to prospective investors during roadshows to drum up support ahead of this week’s successful bond swap deal.
“Residential property prices have further to fall but the commercial market has probably bottomed,” the review says.
The NTMA is the state agency responsible for managing the national debt and controls NAMA, the biggest owner of commercial property in the country and the biggest owner of residential property after the State.
Resilient
The outlook for the property sector was part of a mostly upbeat economic assessment. The NTMA said the economy grew last year for the first time since 2007, thanks to exports that have so far remained resilient despite the global slowdown.
Economic conditions are improving but the NTMA warns the success seen so far could be under threat. Domestic demand may continue to fall this year, hurting the chances of general growth in the economy, the report adds.
It notes families are getting poorer and disposable income has fallen every year since 2008 due to rising taxes and falling wages. Household wealth is back to 2003 levels.
The NTMA says the reduction in the interest rate Europe charges for bailout loans helped make those kind of trends easier to swallow for struggling families. But even with Ireland doing all it can to hit fiscal targets, the euro crisis could still prove a threat to exports, and therefore to the entire recovery.
On a more upbeat note the NTMA says that Ireland is now living within its means — with a current account surplus. The banks have been successfully recapitalised, the threat to the 12.5pc corporation tax rate is gone and the economy has started to become more competitive. The presentation says NAMA could make an operating profit of €600m for 2011.
- Donal O’Donovan
Irish Independent